Food & Drink · 3 min read
How to judge a Yorkshire pudding, properly
What separates a proper Yorkshire pudding from a pale impostor — and how to order one well on a Sunday.
Yorkshire Unlocked · November 2026

Every Yorkshire household has an opinion about the pudding, and most of them come down to the same four things: how high it rose, what it was cooked in, how much gravy it took, and whether it arrived before the meat or beside it. Get those right and you have something extraordinary for about forty pence a portion. Get them wrong and you have a flat, greasy pancake with a roast attached.
What a good one looks like
The rise is not vanity, it is structure. A proper pudding has climbed the sides of its tin and hollowed out in the middle, with a crisp dark rim and a soft, custardy base. If it is pale, level and thin, either the oven was not hot enough or the tin went in cold. Beef dripping gives the best colour and flavour; oil will work, but it will not taste of anything.
Batter wants resting, not beating. An hour in the fridge does more for a pudding than any amount of whisking, and a pinch of salt does more than most recipes admit.
The order of service
Traditionally it comes first, with onion gravy and nothing else, because a large pudding was how you stopped a hungry family eating a week's meat in one sitting. Plenty of pubs still serve it that way and they are right. A pudding brought out underneath the beef, sagging under the weight of it, is a waste of a good crust.
A Yorkshire pudding is not a side dish. It is the first course, and the argument for it is on the plate.
How to order well
Ask whether the puddings are made to order or held warm in a tray. Ask what fat is used. If the answer to the second question is a shrug, order something else and enjoy the pub for what it is. Portion size is not a substitute for technique — a huge, soggy pudding is a bigger disappointment than a small, correct one.
Practical tips
- Book Sunday lunch for 12.00 or after 2.30. The 1.30 sitting is when kitchens rush and puddings sit.
- In the Dales and the Moors, most good pubs take bookings; on the coast, walk-ins are more normal outside July and August.
- If you only have one Yorkshire meal, make it a Sunday lunch in a village pub rather than a city chain.
- Vegetarians: ask for the pudding with onion gravy rather than a nut roast. It is usually the better plate.
Our restaurant guide is sorted by area, so you can find the nearest pub doing it properly wherever you happen to be.
Keep reading


